While I find it obvious that transsexualism is real, delusion and confusion are also real, and the young are especially vulnerable here.
I think the problem is that the question of gender has been politicised, with some giving the false impression that everyone who claims to have gender dysphoria is perverted or delusional, while others give the false impression that everyone to claims gender dysphoria is rational and not confused.
If I question an AI : "What is a man?", it says:
A man is defined as an adult male human. This classification distinguishes him from boys, who are male children or adolescents. The biological characteristics that define a man include the presence of XY chromosomes, with the Y chromosome being responsible for male sex differentiation through the SRY gene. This gene triggers the development of male reproductive organs during fetal development.
Biological Characteristics
Men typically possess primary sex characteristics such as the penis and testicles, which are integral to reproduction. During puberty, secondary sexual characteristics develop due to hormonal changes, particularly from testosterone. These changes include increased muscle mass, greater height, facial hair growth, and a deeper voice compared to females.
Social and Cultural Aspects
Throughout history, men have often been associated with specific social roles and responsibilities. Traditional gender roles frequently place men in positions of authority or as providers within families. In many cultures, masculinity is linked to traits such as strength, courage, and assertiveness. However, these roles can vary significantly across different societies and historical contexts.
Health Considerations
Men face unique health challenges compared to women. While they may be overrepresented in certain dangerous occupations and military service—leading to higher mortality rates in those areas—they also experience disparities in healthcare access and treatment outcomes.
Gender Identity
In contemporary discussions about gender, it is important to recognize that not all individuals who identify as men fit traditional definitions based on biological sex alone. Trans men are individuals assigned female at birth but who identify and live as men. Intersex individuals may possess physical characteristics that do not fit typical definitions of male or female biology.
Conclusion
In summary, a man is an adult male human characterized by specific biological traits but also shaped by cultural expectations and individual identity.
It's a very different answer to "What is a woman?":
The question “What is a woman?” has been the subject of extensive discussion and debate, particularly in the context of gender identity and societal definitions. Traditionally, the term “woman” has been defined biologically as an adult female human being, typically characterized by the ability to bear offspring or produce eggs. However, this definition does not encompass the complexities of gender identity that have emerged in contemporary discourse.
Biological Perspective
From a biological standpoint, women are often defined based on their reproductive anatomy and secondary sexual characteristics. This includes features such as breasts, wider hips, and the presence of two X chromosomes. However, this perspective can be limiting because it does not account for intersex individuals or those who may identify as women but do not conform to traditional biological definitions.
Gender Identity Perspective
In recent years, there has been a significant shift towards understanding gender as a spectrum rather than a binary classification. Gender identity refers to an individual’s personal sense of their own gender, which may or may not align with their biological sex assigned at birth. Many people now define a woman as someone who identifies as female, regardless of their biological characteristics. This definition recognizes that womanhood can be experienced in diverse ways and is influenced by social, cultural, and individual factors.
Cultural Context
Culturally, the concept of what it means to be a woman varies significantly across different societies and communities. In some cultures, traditional roles associated with women may include caregiving or homemaking, while in others, women may take on leadership roles in various sectors. The evolving nature of these roles reflects broader societal changes regarding gender equality and women’s rights.
Conclusion
Ultimately, a woman is someone who identifies as female, encompassing both those who are biologically female and those who are transgender or non-binary individuals who embrace femininity in various forms. The definition of “woman” is thus multifaceted and shaped by personal identity rather than solely by biological criteria.
Logically, there should be no difference in the answers, but AI simply picks up predominant views online.
This false blurring of lines and bias is the problem. I don't think such manipulations and selective post-modernism do transpeople any favours. In fact, my guess is that most transpeople would wish that people would simply stop talking about them and let them get on with living their lives as best they can, which would usually mean quietly and anonymously.
Imagine having so much of the world discussing your genitals and very private parts of your life, kicking you around like a political football. I think most of us would find that distasteful. As always, the mainstream media is culpable. Trans issues are related to sex, and sex sells.
- By Fanman
- By Thrylix
- By The Beast